141 CJ Alexander – The Podcasters

Wrapping up the CJ Alexander series, we sit down with Christian Babcock and Jake Gaylord, the dynamic duo behind the popular Hunters Advantage podcast. In early 2024, Alexander made a memorable appearance on their podcast, spinning his well-worn underdog tale of an unbelievably lucky trophy buck – a tale that took a dramatic turn when it was later revealed he had already confessed to poaching it.  

Our Sponsors:

Thin Green Line Podcast

Don Noyes Chevrolet

North American Game Warden Museum

Hunt Regs

SecureIt Gun Storage

XS Sights

“A Cowboy in the Woods” Book

Maine’s Operation Game Thief

International Wildlife Crimestoppers

Here’s what we discuss:

  • Christian posts, then removes, a video questioning the Alexander buck
  • Hunters Advantage podcast invites Alexander to tell his story
  • All large deer taken can be controversial
  • Alexander tells the hosts a convincing enough tale
  • “I came out of it with kind of an uneasy feeling.”
  • Alexander had appeared on the podcast after confessing to game wardens
  • The court-ordered apology letter
  • Public opinion was split
  • Misdemeanor charges moved to felony levels
  • Podcast appearances could have been used in sentencing
  • Technology makes poaching hard to hide
  • Antlers are like fingerprints
  • Podcast generated both positive and negative feedback
  • “We’re just common men with a nice microphone.”

Credits

Hosts: Wayne Saunders and John Nores

Producer: Jay Ammann

Warden’s Watch logo & Design: Ashley Hannett

Research / Content Coordinator: Stacey DesRoches

Subscribe:

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

Amazon

Google

Waypoint

Stitcher

TuneIn

Megaphone

Find More Here:

Website

Warden’s Watch / TGL Store

Facebook

Facebook Fan Page

Instagram

Threads

YouTube

RSS

140 CJ Alexander – The Wardens

Picking up from our last episode, we sit down with two of the Ohio game wardens responsible for bringing this case before the court. Wildlife Officers Isaiah Gifford and Matt Roberts outline the meticulous effort and tiny details that led to the indictment and ultimate guilty plea of the now-infamous poacher, CJ Alexander.

See this episode on YouTube here: EP140 CJ Alexander Buck The Officer’s interview

Our Sponsors:

Thin Green Line Podcast

Don Noyes Chevrolet

North American Game Warden Museum

Hunt Regs

SecureIt Gun Storage

XS Sights

“A Cowboy in the Woods” Book

Maine’s Operation Game Thief

International Wildlife Crimestoppers

Here’s what we discuss:

  • Investigation began as a typical follow up when a trophy animal is taken
  • Alexander spins his tale
  • Wildlife officers visit the alleged kill site
  • The staged site seems unusual, but mostly believable
  • A video arrives showing the animal 10 miles away
  • Wardens take a closer look
  • A bait pile and other evidence is found
  • Trail camera photos show the deer in the area
  • A grid search locates more evidence
  • Tiny details in a photo confirm officers’ suspicions
  • “There’s a knife – and there’s another knife!”
  • Alexander admits lying about the site
  • Antlers had already been sold, and are confiscated
  • Foliage at the supposed kill site does not match photos
  • Search warrants solidify the evidence
  • The poacher continues to make false claims publicly
  • Charges include tampering with evidence and theft by deception
  • Investigators meticulously pore through the evidence
  • “At the end of the day, we knew what we had.”
  • An Ohio record for restitution

Credits

Hosts: Wayne Saunders and John Nores

Producer: Jay Ammann

Warden’s Watch logo & Design: Ashley Hannett

Research / Content Coordinator: Stacey DesRoches

Subscribe:

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

Amazon

Google

Waypoint

Stitcher

TuneIn

Megaphone

Find More Here:

Website

Warden’s Watch / TGL Store

Facebook

Facebook Fan Page

Instagram

Threads

YouTube

RSS

139 CJ Alexander – The Facts

For a time, Christopher “CJ” Alexander seemed to be everywhere; on the news in his native Ohio, in magazine articles, and featured on various hunting-related podcasts, telling the tale again and again of how he took a massive 18-point buck – a trophy in the running to be among the top three typical whitetails of all time.  In the end, fame turned into felony charges, and the windfall he expected became instead a whopping $43,000 in fines. Hear the facts as read by an investigator involved in the case.

See this episode on YouTube here:  https://youtu.be/w_rulXxzkKE

Our Sponsors:

Thin Green Line Podcast

Don Noyes Chevrolet

North American Game Warden Museum

Hunt Regs

SecureIt Gun Storage

XS Sights

“A Cowboy in the Woods” Book

Maine’s Operation Game Thief

International Wildlife Crimestoppers

Here’s what we discuss:

  • Wayne reads a note from Alexander
  • Deer becomes an internet sensation
  • Everyone loved the underdog story
  • Ohio DNR follows up
  • Information casts doubt on Alexander’s story
  • A photo and legwork begin to unravel the lies
  • Animal was poached on private property
  • Cell phone records reveal a plan
  • They name the buck Megatron
  • “Buying a house type money.”
  • Alexander shoots the buck… poorly
  • The deer is found and removed under cover of darkness
  • An elaborate cover up is put into motion
  • High expectations for big profits
  • “Can cell phone location data be used as evidence against me?”
  • Alexander pleads guilty to 14 charges
  • Deer was targeted solely for money and fame

Credits

Hosts: Wayne Saunders and John Nores

Producer: Jay Ammann

Warden’s Watch logo & Design: Ashley Hannett

Research / Content Coordinator: Stacey DesRoches

Subscribe:

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

Amazon

Google

Waypoint

Stitcher

TuneIn

Megaphone

Find More Here:

Website

Warden’s Watch / TGL Store

Facebook

Facebook Fan Page

Instagram

Threads

YouTube

RSS

UPDATE: CJ Alexander – CONVICTED

In late 2023, an 18-point trophy whitetail buck was taken illegally in Ohio. After an intense, high-profile investigation, several men pleaded guilty and were sentenced. The ringleader of the group also pled guilty and was sentenced this week to 90 days in jail and ordered to pay a combined $43,000 in penalties. 

Our Sponsors:

Thin Green Line Podcast

Don Noyes Chevrolet

North American Game Warden Museum

Sovereign Sportsman Solutions

“A Cowboy in the Woods” Book

Hunt of a Lifetime

Maine’s Operation Game Thief

Wildlife Heritage Foundation of NH

International Wildlife Crimestoppers

Credits

Hosts: Wayne Saunders and John Nores

Producer: Jay Ammann

Warden’s Watch logo & Design: Ashley Hannett

Research / Content Coordinator: Stacey DesRoches

Subscribe:

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

Amazon

Google

Waypoint

Stitcher

TuneIn

Megaphone

Find More Here:

Website

Warden’s Watch / TGL Store

Facebook

Facebook Fan Page

Instagram

Threads

YouTube

RSS